Portfolio management art or science?

Dr Costas Chryssou

Mar 20, 2022

tamegon Innovation and Growth Advisory Firm

Senior managers and PMO staff, in all organisations, increasingly recognise that one of the most efficient ways of ensuring that their projects and programmes deliver the intended value for the organisation is through formal portfolio management.


A recent PMI survey [1] reported that 55% of organisations frequently use formal portfolio management, a 5% increase over the previous year. Similarly, a PwC survey [2] reports that 53% of respondents across industries and sectors from retail, insurance, auto, banking to manufacturing and telecommunications, use portfolio management techniques and methodologies.


Effective portfolio management entails the constant allocation of scarce resources to projects by balancing cost, risk, and financial or strategic benefits or risk avoidance and any dependencies between projects. The task is complex and onerous since many options of viable combinations of project portfolios are present and multiple stakeholders, sometimes with conflicting agendas, compete for scarce resources.


Portfolio management allows the executive team to obtain a holistic view across the group of projects and programmes allowing them to understand the portfolio's value and strategic alignment - 'show me your project portfolio and I will show you your strategy'. Portfolio management employs three basic approaches:

  • value maximisation,
  • resource optimisation,
  • risk diversification.


Portfolio management involves ‘art’ and ‘science’ skills.


I used in the blog’s title the question “portfolio management: ‘art’ or ‘science?" because I recently came across an article explaining how Google has built  image recognition software that enables an artificial neural network of computers to see shapes in images; the by-product of this is some surprisingly creative and unusual pictures [3] – culmination of ‘art’ and ‘science’! This is also the case with portfolio management.


The ‘science’ part may entail plotting all possible portfolio combinations to identify those that represent best value for money; based on the constraints we have imposed (cost, benefit, risk, resources and inter-dependencies, and any possible mandatory projects). These value-for-money portfolio picks represent the ‘efficient frontier’ of the portfolio – the portfolios along the top edge of the plot cluster, as shown in the schematic.

Risk-Adjusted Efficient Frontier - tamegon.com

Such an approach not only allows us to identify the most high value portfolio combinations, but also to directly compare portfolio picks that include both financial and strategic benefits, and plot risk-adjusted values against risk-adjusted costs on a scale of arbitrary units; the scale will be a reflection of the value that the organisation puts on the various benefit categories.


And here is where the ‘art’ part comes into play. The efficient frontier methodology, although powerful and value-adding, cannot substitute for effective decision-making from the senior executive team. It is senior executives that need to select the most appropriate portfolio best aligned to the strategy of the organisation and it is for them to determine the type and balance of benefits they are looking to realise by executing the 'right' portfolio of projects.


Find out how our project portfolio optimisation tool can assist your organisation with maximising value from your change and innovation project portfolio here.


[1] http://www.pmi.org/~/media/PDF/Research/2012_Pulse_of_the_profession.ashx

[2] http://www.pwc.com/mx/es/industrias/proyectos-capital/archivo/7930526410-insight-trends.pdf

[3] https://news.artnet.com/market/google-inceptionism-art-sells-big-7930526410

Costas Chryssou MBA, PhD
Founder and Managing Director

Sign up for our articles

Sign up to our newsletter

Digital change, transformation, and metamorphosis
By Dr Costas Chryssou 08 Jun, 2023
Digital transformation (DT) market is projected to grow at a higher than 20% compounded annual growth rate from 2023 with an associated spending of 1.6 $trillion in 2022 and a projected spending forecast of 3.4 $trillion in 2026. Although this astonishing growth is attributed mainly to the Covid-19 pandemic, which since 2020 caused many organisations to increase significantly their investment and adoption of digital, there are many other contributing factors at play including changing customers' behaviours, preferences, and needs. While digital transformation is a necessity for all organisations to remain competitive, the term is often overused, sometimes confusing businesses and practitioners alike. Many times the terms digitisation, digitalisation, and digital transformation are used interchangeably, together with digital change and even metamorphosis. So what do they all mean and what are their benefits for an organisation? Digitisation is about converting analogue data into digital form and it is the first step that organisations need to take in their digital journey towards digital transformation. Digitisation enables businesses to gain valuable insights from their data, leading to advanced business analytics and the capability of informed decision-making processes. By digitisation, many businesses, that still use manual processes to interact with their customers, can move a step closer to enhancing their customer experience. Digitalisation , on the other hand, involves the change of workflows and the adaptation of organisational processes, procedures, and systems to enable the adoption of digital technologies. Through their digitalisation efforts, organisations can leverage digitisation to improve their business processes through automation, enrich their products or services, and offer enhanced value to their customers. For example, an organisation could be using digitised customer data, as gained from different sources, to automatically generate insights from their behaviour and inform existing products and services and create new ones. Although the transition path may not be linear, digitisation and digitalisation lead to digital transformation. Digital transformation builds on the above described digitisation and digitalisation efforts and prepares organisations to leverage their knowledge and integrate it in all business areas to enhance customer engagement and experience, innovate their business model, and create new value. By utilising digital technologies, successfully implemented digital transformation projects make organisations more agile in responding to changing markets and disruptive business models, thereby making them more resilient to external disruption. Through digital transformation, organisations can achieve significant growth and gain competitive advantage. “…Digital transformation is the integration of digital technology into all areas of a business, fundamentally changing how it operates and delivers value to customers…”
ERP vendor evaluation and selection criteria
By Dr Costas Chryssou 22 Feb, 2023
This article outlines the criteria for evaluating and selecting ERP vendors that universities and HEIs should consider using to maximise ROI for their organisation.
How to innovate a Project Management Office
By Dr Costas Chryssou 11 Sep, 2022
Recent surveys indicate that more than 50% of Project Management Offices (PMOs) [1] have been in existence for less than two years. This article comments on how to bring innovation into the PMO so that it remains relevant to the needs of the organisation.
Innovation_Management_Frameworks_tamegon.com
By Dr Costas Chryssou 24 Aug, 2022
It seems that most articles, presentations and websites represent innovation using lightbulb images putting the focus and emphasis of the whole innovation process, it seems, entirely on the eureka moment - the lightbulb moment. However is this the most significant step in the innovation process? This article outlines the drawbacks of associating innovation only with creativity and proposes the use of innovation management frameworks for organisations to be more successful in their innovation pursuits.
Benefit attribution of change and innovation projects
By Dr Costas Chryssou 10 Jun, 2022
Although benefit attribution of a project is very important to any organisation, it is considered very hard to implement and therefore organisations do not put any concerted efforts behind it. This article recommends the development of a ‘line of sight’ between the intended benefits, the changes to the organisational blueprint and the project deliverables in order to ensure that the "right" projects are implemented.
Build or Buy an ERP solution?
By Dr Costas Chryssou 09 Jun, 2022
This article builds the case around the advantages and disadvantages of building an ERP solution versus purchasing one from a well established vendor.
Types of an Innovation PMO
By Dr Costas Chryssou 27 Feb, 2022
This article discusses possible types of Innovation PMO that can be implemented by organisations in order to support their innovation and growth ambitions. It discusses structures such as promoter, incubator, champion
Organisational structures of an Innovation PMO
By Dr Costas Chryssou 27 Feb, 2022
This article describes a number of structures that an innovation PMO can take such as centralised, decentralised and hub and spoke. It also describes the broad skills that Innovation PMO staff should have.
From strategy to implementation and organisational benefits
By Dr Costas Chryssou 21 Feb, 2022
This article discusses the difficulties that organisations have implementing their vision and strategies and proposes a model to enable a better implementation and success of such endeavours.
Can blockchain technologies transform the government and public sector?
By Dr Costas Chryssou 14 Feb, 2022
This article explores blockchain-based technologies as appropriate to transform governments and public sector organisations. It provides an overview of the technology, challenges of adoption and an update on what is happening in the Middle East.
More Posts
Share by: